The toughest course in the Youngstown-Warren, OH metro area is Avalon Lakes Golf Course, at slope 139 — ahead of Squaw Creek Golf Course at slope 134 and Mill Creek Golf Course (South) at slope 129.
All 17 courses in the area with a USGA slope rating for its men’s tees are ranked below, along with 5 more lists: hardest from the tips, longest, widest tee spread, oldest, highest above sea level.
Youngstown-Warren, OH is a metro area as the U.S. Office of Management and Budget delineates it — the boundary is theirs, not ours. Each list counts only the courses in the area that publish that figure, so the totals differ between them. Slope and course rating measure difficulty, not quality — nothing here ranks how good a course is.
Toughest test
— all 17 courses with a USGA slope rating for its men’s tees
| # | Course | Toughest test |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Avalon Lakes Golf Course | slope 139 |
| 2 | Squaw Creek Golf Course | slope 134 |
| 3 | Mill Creek Golf Course (South) | slope 129 |
| 3 | Pine Lakes Golf Club | slope 129 |
| 5 | Youngstown Country Club | slope 128 |
| 6 | Mill Creek Golf Course (North) | slope 124 |
| 7 | Yankee Run Golf Course | slope 123 |
| 8 | The Lake Club | slope 121 |
| 9 | Knoll Run Golf Course | slope 120 |
| 10 | Old Avalon Golf Course | slope 118 |
| 11 | Riverview Golf Course | slope 116 |
| 12 | Bedford Trails Golf Course | slope 115 |
| 12 | Reserve Run Golf Course | slope 115 |
| 14 | Hidden Oaks Golf Course | slope 113 |
| 15 | Deer Creek Golf Course | slope 110 |
| 15 | Henry Stambaugh Golf Course | slope 110 |
| 15 | Mahoning Country Club | slope 110 |
The highest USGA slope rating published for any of the men’s tee sets. Slope rates difficulty for a bogey golfer relative to a scratch golfer — a rated figure issued by the golf association, not an opinion about the course. Men’s ratings only, because a tee is rated separately for men and for women and the two scales do not compare; a course rated only for women is not in the running rather than converted.
Hardest from the tips
— all 15 courses with a USGA course rating for its men’s tees
| # | Course | Hardest from the tips |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Avalon Lakes Golf Course | rating 76.5 |
| 2 | Squaw Creek Golf Course | rating 75.2 |
| 3 | Mill Creek Golf Course (South) | rating 74.9 |
| 4 | Mill Creek Golf Course (North) | rating 73.9 |
| 5 | Pine Lakes Golf Club | rating 71.8 |
| 5 | Youngstown Country Club | rating 71.8 |
| 7 | Riverview Golf Course | rating 71.6 |
| 8 | The Lake Club | rating 71.3 |
| 9 | Knoll Run Golf Course | rating 71.2 |
| 10 | Yankee Run Golf Course | rating 71.1 |
| 11 | Old Avalon Golf Course | rating 70.8 |
| 12 | Mahoning Country Club | rating 70.0 |
| 13 | Reserve Run Golf Course | rating 68.1 |
| 14 | Deer Creek Golf Course | rating 67.1 |
| 15 | Bedford Trails Golf Course | rating 67.0 |
The highest USGA course rating published for any of the men’s tee sets — the score a scratch golfer is expected to shoot. Men’s ratings only, for the same reason as slope: the men’s and women’s ratings of one tee are different measurements. It measures difficulty and nothing else; it is not a quality score and never orders these pages by how good a course is.
Longest
— the top 25 of 26 courses with a published scorecard
| # | Course | Longest |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Avalon Lakes Golf Course | 7,551 yds |
| 2 | Squaw Creek Golf Course | 7,372 yds |
| 3 | Tippecanoe Country Club | 6,878 yds |
| 4 | Riverview Golf Course | 6,690 yds |
| 5 | Youngstown Country Club | 6,663 yds |
| 6 | Pine Lakes Golf Club | 6,612 yds |
| 7 | The Lake Club | 6,543 yds |
| 8 | Olde Dutch Mill Golf Course | 6,537 yds |
| 9 | Old Avalon Golf Course | 6,528 yds |
| 10 | Knoll Run Golf Course | 6,525 yds |
| 11 | Yankee Run Golf Course | 6,516 yds |
| 11 | Yankee Run Golf Course | 6,516 yds |
| 13 | Mill Creek Golf Course (South) | 6,511 yds |
| 14 | Mill Creek Golf Course (North) | 6,412 yds |
| 15 | Bedford Trails Golf Course | 6,340 yds |
| 16 | Tamer Win Golf & Country Club | 6,292 yds |
| 17 | Bronzwood Golf Club | 6,269 yds |
| 17 | Bronzwood Golf Club | 6,269 yds |
| 19 | Reserve Run Golf Course | 6,162 yds |
| 20 | Deer Creek Golf Course | 6,022 yds |
| 20 | Deer Creek Golf Course | 6,022 yds |
| 22 | Mahoning Country Club | 6,006 yds |
| 23 | Henry Stambaugh Golf Course | 3,420 yds |
| 24 | Northwood Golf Course | 3,234 yds |
| 25 | Hidden Oaks Golf Course | 3,061 yds |
The longest tee set the course publishes, in yards from the tips. Compared against every course that publishes a scorecard — length is a measurement, not a verdict on the golf.
Widest tee spread
— all 25 courses with two or more tee sets of different lengths
| # | Course | Widest tee spread |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Olde Dutch Mill Golf Course | 3,690 yds between tees |
| 2 | Yankee Run Golf Course | 2,882 yds between tees |
| 3 | Avalon Lakes Golf Course | 2,647 yds between tees |
| 4 | Squaw Creek Golf Course | 2,382 yds between tees |
| 5 | Knoll Run Golf Course | 1,910 yds between tees |
| 6 | Old Avalon Golf Course | 1,898 yds between tees |
| 7 | Tippecanoe Country Club | 1,849 yds between tees |
| 8 | Pine Lakes Golf Club | 1,790 yds between tees |
| 9 | Reserve Run Golf Course | 1,657 yds between tees |
| 10 | Yankee Run Golf Course | 1,580 yds between tees |
| 11 | The Lake Club | 1,486 yds between tees |
| 12 | Riverview Golf Course | 1,484 yds between tees |
| 13 | Deer Creek Golf Course | 1,301 yds between tees |
| 13 | Deer Creek Golf Course | 1,301 yds between tees |
| 15 | Bronzwood Golf Club | 1,290 yds between tees |
| 15 | Bronzwood Golf Club | 1,290 yds between tees |
| 17 | Mill Creek Golf Course (North) | 1,240 yds between tees |
| 18 | Youngstown Country Club | 1,206 yds between tees |
| 19 | Bedford Trails Golf Course | 1,177 yds between tees |
| 20 | Mill Creek Golf Course (South) | 1,107 yds between tees |
| 21 | Tamer Win Golf & Country Club | 1,076 yds between tees |
| 22 | Mahoning Country Club | 926 yds between tees |
| 23 | Henry Stambaugh Golf Course | 360 yds between tees |
| 24 | Hidden Oaks Golf Course | 326 yds between tees |
| 25 | Northwood Golf Course | 315 yds between tees |
Yards between the longest and shortest published tee sets — how far the course moves to fit a different player. Courses publishing a single tee set are not in the running, because one set is an unmeasured spread rather than a narrow one.
Oldest
— all 18 courses with an opening year
| # | Course | Oldest |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Youngstown Country Club | opened 1911 |
| 2 | Mahoning Country Club | opened 1922 |
| 2 | Squaw Creek Golf Course | opened 1922 |
| 4 | Henry Stambaugh Golf Course | opened 1923 |
| 5 | Mill Creek Golf Course (North) | opened 1927 |
| 5 | Pine Lakes Golf Club | opened 1927 |
| 7 | Old Avalon Golf Course | opened 1928 |
| 8 | Mill Creek Golf Course (South) | opened 1930 |
| 9 | Yankee Run Golf Course | opened 1931 |
| 10 | The Lake Club | opened 1960 |
| 11 | Hidden Oaks Golf Course | opened 1961 |
| 12 | Riverview Golf Course | opened 1962 |
| 13 | Avalon Lakes Golf Course | opened 1967 |
| 14 | Deer Creek Golf Course | opened 1969 |
| 15 | Bedford Trails Golf Course | opened 1985 |
| 16 | Reserve Run Golf Course | opened 1999 |
| 17 | Knoll Run Golf Course | opened 2007 |
| 18 | Parto's Big On Golf | opened 2010 |
The year the course opened, as published. Ranked oldest first. An opening year is not a design credit and not a renovation date — a course that opened in 1921 and was rebuilt in 1998 still opened in 1921.
Highest above sea level
— the top 25 of 27 courses with a coordinate we could sample
| # | Course | Highest above sea level |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hidden Oaks Golf Course | 1,192 ft |
| 2 | Reserve Run Golf Course | 1,191 ft |
| 3 | The Lake Club | 1,141 ft |
| 4 | Squaw Creek Golf Course | 1,134 ft |
| 5 | Bedford Trails Golf Course | 1,132 ft |
| 6 | Knoll Run Golf Course | 1,123 ft |
| 7 | Parto's Big On Golf | 1,080 ft |
| 7 | Tippecanoe Country Club | 1,080 ft |
| 9 | Bronzwood Golf Club | 1,077 ft |
| 10 | Avalon Lakes Golf Course | 1,072 ft |
| 11 | Bronzwood Golf Club | 1,069 ft |
| 12 | Old Avalon Golf Course | 1,065 ft |
| 13 | Henry Stambaugh Golf Course | 1,043 ft |
| 14 | Mill Creek Metroparks Par-3 Golf Course | 1,035 ft |
| 15 | Tamer Win Golf & Country Club | 1,031 ft |
| 16 | Mahoning Country Club | 1,002 ft |
| 17 | Mill Creek Golf Course (North) | 1,001 ft |
| 18 | Pine Lakes Golf Club | 999 ft |
| 19 | Mill Creek Golf Course (South) | 998 ft |
| 20 | Deer Creek Golf Course | 955 ft |
| 21 | Youngstown Country Club | 941 ft |
| 22 | Deer Creek Golf Course | 928 ft |
| 23 | Northwood Golf Course | 924 ft |
| 23 | Yankee Run Golf Course | 924 ft |
| 25 | Olde Dutch Mill Golf Course | 922 ft |
Height above sea level at the course’s own published coordinate, sampled from the USGS 3DEP elevation model. THIS IS A FIGURE WE DERIVED, not one the course publishes — anybody can re-query the same public dataset at the same coordinate and get the same number, but no scorecard states it. Because every course carries a coordinate, this is the only board here whose field is nearly the whole database rather than the courses that publish a particular figure. Elevation changes how far a ball carries; it says nothing about whether a course is good.