The toughest course in the Lancaster, PA metro area is Bent Creek Country Club, at slope 139 — ahead of Pilgrims Oak Golf Course at slope 135 and Conestoga Country Club at slope 131.
All 15 courses in the area with a USGA slope rating for its men’s tees are ranked below, along with 5 more lists: hardest from the tips, longest, widest tee spread, oldest, highest above sea level.
Lancaster, PA is a metro area as the U.S. Office of Management and Budget delineates it — the boundary is theirs, not ours. Each list counts only the courses in the area that publish that figure, so the totals differ between them. Slope and course rating measure difficulty, not quality — nothing here ranks how good a course is.
Toughest test
— all 15 courses with a USGA slope rating for its men’s tees
| # | Course | Toughest test |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bent Creek Country Club | slope 139 |
| 2 | Pilgrims Oak Golf Course | slope 135 |
| 3 | Conestoga Country Club | slope 131 |
| 4 | Meadia Heights Golf Club | slope 130 |
| 5 | Hawk Valley Golf Club | slope 128 |
| 6 | Overlook Golf Course | slope 127 |
| 7 | Foxchase Golf Club | slope 124 |
| 8 | Crossgates Golf Course | slope 123 |
| 9 | Tanglewood Manor Golf Club | slope 122 |
| 10 | Highlands of Donegal Golf Course | slope 121 |
| 11 | Four Seasons Golf Course | slope 120 |
| 12 | Executive at Evergreen Golf Course Inc | slope 119 |
| 13 | Willow Valley Golf Course | slope 107 |
| 14 | Tree Top Golf Course | slope 99 |
| 15 | New Holland Pitch Putt | slope 93 |
The highest USGA slope rating published for any of the men’s tee sets. Slope rates difficulty for a bogey golfer relative to a scratch golfer — a rated figure issued by the golf association, not an opinion about the course. Men’s ratings only, because a tee is rated separately for men and for women and the two scales do not compare; a course rated only for women is not in the running rather than converted.
Hardest from the tips
— all 12 courses with a USGA course rating for its men’s tees
| # | Course | Hardest from the tips |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bent Creek Country Club | rating 73.0 |
| 2 | Pilgrims Oak Golf Course | rating 72.3 |
| 3 | Conestoga Country Club | rating 72.0 |
| 4 | Foxchase Golf Club | rating 71.9 |
| 5 | Hawk Valley Golf Club | rating 71.3 |
| 6 | Tanglewood Manor Golf Club | rating 70.8 |
| 7 | Highlands of Donegal Golf Course | rating 70.6 |
| 8 | Overlook Golf Course | rating 70.5 |
| 9 | Crossgates Golf Course | rating 70.1 |
| 10 | Four Seasons Golf Course | rating 69.6 |
| 11 | Meadia Heights Golf Club | rating 69.5 |
| 12 | Tree Top Golf Course | rating 64.2 |
The highest USGA course rating published for any of the men’s tee sets — the score a scratch golfer is expected to shoot. Men’s ratings only, for the same reason as slope: the men’s and women’s ratings of one tee are different measurements. It measures difficulty and nothing else; it is not a quality score and never orders these pages by how good a course is.
Longest
— all 17 courses with a published scorecard
| # | Course | Longest |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Lancaster Host Golf Resort | 6,849 yds |
| 2 | Pilgrims Oak Golf Course | 6,766 yds |
| 3 | Bent Creek Country Club | 6,660 yds |
| 4 | Foxchase Golf Club | 6,607 yds |
| 5 | Conestoga Country Club | 6,480 yds |
| 6 | Highlands of Donegal Golf Course | 6,403 yds |
| 7 | Hawk Valley Golf Club | 6,380 yds |
| 8 | Tanglewood Manor Golf Club | 6,379 yds |
| 9 | Four Seasons Golf Course | 6,320 yds |
| 10 | Overlook Golf Course | 6,205 yds |
| 11 | Meadia Heights Golf Club | 6,197 yds |
| 12 | Crossgates Golf Course | 6,151 yds |
| 13 | Tree Top Golf Course | 4,651 yds |
| 14 | Executive at Evergreen Golf Course Inc | 4,569 yds |
| 15 | Willow Valley Golf Course | 2,367 yds |
| 16 | Pitch and Putt at Evergreen Golf Course Inc | 1,553 yds |
| 17 | Springside Par 3 Golf Course | 1,193 yds |
The longest tee set the course publishes, in yards from the tips. Compared against every course that publishes a scorecard — length is a measurement, not a verdict on the golf.
Widest tee spread
— all 14 courses with two or more tee sets of different lengths
| # | Course | Widest tee spread |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Foxchase Golf Club | 1,854 yds between tees |
| 2 | Pilgrims Oak Golf Course | 1,845 yds between tees |
| 3 | Overlook Golf Course | 1,665 yds between tees |
| 4 | Bent Creek Country Club | 1,540 yds between tees |
| 4 | Highlands of Donegal Golf Course | 1,540 yds between tees |
| 6 | Lancaster Host Golf Resort | 1,438 yds between tees |
| 7 | Crossgates Golf Course | 1,413 yds between tees |
| 8 | Four Seasons Golf Course | 1,332 yds between tees |
| 9 | Hawk Valley Golf Club | 1,298 yds between tees |
| 10 | Conestoga Country Club | 1,142 yds between tees |
| 11 | Tanglewood Manor Golf Club | 1,058 yds between tees |
| 12 | Meadia Heights Golf Club | 640 yds between tees |
| 13 | Willow Valley Golf Course | 413 yds between tees |
| 14 | Tree Top Golf Course | 370 yds between tees |
Yards between the longest and shortest published tee sets — how far the course moves to fit a different player. Courses publishing a single tee set are not in the running, because one set is an unmeasured spread rather than a narrow one.
Oldest
— all 15 courses with an opening year
| # | Course | Oldest |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Meadia Heights Golf Club | opened 1922 |
| 2 | Overlook Golf Course | opened 1928 |
| 3 | Conestoga Country Club | opened 1948 |
| 4 | Four Seasons Golf Course | opened 1962 |
| 5 | Tanglewood Manor Golf Club | opened 1967 |
| 6 | Executive at Evergreen Golf Course Inc | opened 1969 |
| 7 | Hawk Valley Golf Club | opened 1971 |
| 8 | Tree Top Golf Course | opened 1975 |
| 8 | Willow Valley Golf Course | opened 1975 |
| 10 | Springside Par 3 Golf Course | opened 1989 |
| 11 | Foxchase Golf Club | opened 1991 |
| 12 | Bent Creek Country Club | opened 1992 |
| 13 | Crossgates Golf Course | opened 1994 |
| 14 | Pilgrims Oak Golf Course | opened 1996 |
| 15 | Highlands of Donegal Golf Course | opened 1998 |
The year the course opened, as published. Ranked oldest first. An opening year is not a design credit and not a renovation date — a course that opened in 1921 and was rebuilt in 1998 still opened in 1921.
Highest above sea level
— all 18 courses with a coordinate we could sample
| # | Course | Highest above sea level |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tanglewood Manor Golf Club | 596 ft |
| 2 | Springside Par 3 Golf Course | 523 ft |
| 3 | Tree Top Golf Course | 505 ft |
| 4 | Hawk Valley Golf Club | 500 ft |
| 5 | New Holland Pitch Putt | 480 ft |
| 6 | Foxchase Golf Club | 440 ft |
| 7 | Pilgrims Oak Golf Course | 435 ft |
| 8 | Four Seasons Golf Course | 414 ft |
| 9 | Lancaster Host Golf Resort | 405 ft |
| 10 | Bent Creek Country Club | 387 ft |
| 11 | Pitch and Putt at Evergreen Golf Course Inc | 383 ft |
| 12 | Executive at Evergreen Golf Course Inc | 378 ft |
| 13 | Highlands of Donegal Golf Course | 372 ft |
| 14 | Overlook Golf Course | 363 ft |
| 15 | Willow Valley Golf Course | 347 ft |
| 16 | Meadia Heights Golf Club | 322 ft |
| 17 | Crossgates Golf Course | 292 ft |
| 18 | Conestoga Country Club | 280 ft |
Height above sea level at the course’s own published coordinate, sampled from the USGS 3DEP elevation model. THIS IS A FIGURE WE DERIVED, not one the course publishes — anybody can re-query the same public dataset at the same coordinate and get the same number, but no scorecard states it. Because every course carries a coordinate, this is the only board here whose field is nearly the whole database rather than the courses that publish a particular figure. Elevation changes how far a ball carries; it says nothing about whether a course is good.