The toughest course in the Kiryas Joel-Poughkeepsie-Newburgh, NY metro area is Golf Club at Mansion Ridge, at slope 145 — ahead of Otterkill Golf Country Club at slope 138 and The Links at Union Vale at slope 137.
All 25 courses in the area with a USGA slope rating for its men’s tees are ranked below, along with 5 more lists: hardest from the tips, longest, widest tee spread, oldest, highest above sea level.
Kiryas Joel-Poughkeepsie-Newburgh, NY is a metro area as the U.S. Office of Management and Budget delineates it — the boundary is theirs, not ours. Each list counts only the courses in the area that publish that figure, so the totals differ between them. Slope and course rating measure difficulty, not quality — nothing here ranks how good a course is.
Toughest test
— all 25 courses with a USGA slope rating for its men’s tees
| # | Course | Toughest test |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Golf Club at Mansion Ridge | slope 145 |
| 2 | Otterkill Golf Country Club | slope 138 |
| 3 | The Links at Union Vale | slope 137 |
| 3 | West Point Golf Course | slope 137 |
| 5 | Silo Ridge Field Club | slope 136 |
| 5 | The Tuxedo Club | slope 136 |
| 7 | Millbrook Golf Tennis Club | slope 132 |
| 7 | Red Hook Golf Club | slope 132 |
| 9 | Casperkill Golf Club | slope 130 |
| 10 | Storm King Golf Club | slope 128 |
| 11 | Harlem Valley Golf Club | slope 127 |
| 11 | Stony Ford Golf Course | slope 127 |
| 13 | Mccann Memorial Golf Course | slope 126 |
| 14 | Hickory Hill Golf Course | slope 125 |
| 15 | Beekman Country Club Taconic Highland | slope 122 |
| 15 | Dogwood Knolls Golf Course | slope 122 |
| 15 | Falkirk Estate Country Club | slope 122 |
| 15 | Warwick Valley Country Club | slope 122 |
| 19 | The Lynx at River Bend Golf Club | slope 121 |
| 20 | Beekman Country Club Valley Taconic | slope 119 |
| 21 | Beekman Country Club Highland Valley | slope 117 |
| 22 | Edgewood Club of Tivoli | slope 110 |
| 23 | College Hill Golf Course | slope 107 |
| 24 | Dinsmore Golf Course | slope 106 |
| 25 | Vassar Golf Course | slope 104 |
The highest USGA slope rating published for any of the men’s tee sets. Slope rates difficulty for a bogey golfer relative to a scratch golfer — a rated figure issued by the golf association, not an opinion about the course. Men’s ratings only, because a tee is rated separately for men and for women and the two scales do not compare; a course rated only for women is not in the running rather than converted.
Hardest from the tips
— all 19 courses with a USGA course rating for its men’s tees
| # | Course | Hardest from the tips |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Golf Club at Mansion Ridge | rating 74.9 |
| 2 | Hickory Hill Golf Course | rating 74.2 |
| 3 | Otterkill Golf Country Club | rating 74.1 |
| 4 | The Tuxedo Club | rating 74.0 |
| 5 | The Links at Union Vale | rating 73.3 |
| 6 | Casperkill Golf Club | rating 72.4 |
| 7 | Silo Ridge Field Club | rating 72.1 |
| 8 | Red Hook Golf Club | rating 71.8 |
| 8 | Stony Ford Golf Course | rating 71.8 |
| 10 | Mccann Memorial Golf Course | rating 71.7 |
| 11 | The Lynx at River Bend Golf Club | rating 70.7 |
| 12 | West Point Golf Course | rating 70.5 |
| 13 | Beekman Country Club Taconic Highland | rating 69.6 |
| 13 | Beekman Country Club Valley Taconic | rating 69.6 |
| 15 | Beekman Country Club Highland Valley | rating 69.0 |
| 16 | Falkirk Estate Country Club | rating 67.8 |
| 17 | Edgewood Club of Tivoli | rating 65.8 |
| 18 | Dinsmore Golf Course | rating 65.7 |
| 19 | Vassar Golf Course | rating 32.3 |
The highest USGA course rating published for any of the men’s tee sets — the score a scratch golfer is expected to shoot. Men’s ratings only, for the same reason as slope: the men’s and women’s ratings of one tee are different measurements. It measures difficulty and nothing else; it is not a quality score and never orders these pages by how good a course is.
Longest
— the top 25 of 35 courses with a published scorecard
| # | Course | Longest |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Trump National Golf Club | 7,690 yds |
| 1 | Trump National Golf Club Hudson Valley | 7,690 yds |
| 3 | The Links at Union Vale | 6,954 yds |
| 4 | Golf Club at Mansion Ridge | 6,889 yds |
| 5 | Otterkill Golf Country Club | 6,860 yds |
| 6 | The Tuxedo Club | 6,807 yds |
| 7 | Hickory Hill Golf Course | 6,797 yds |
| 8 | Silo Ridge Field Club | 6,701 yds |
| 9 | Casperkill Golf Club | 6,690 yds |
| 10 | Red Hook Golf Club | 6,564 yds |
| 11 | Stony Ford Golf Course | 6,548 yds |
| 12 | Beekman Country Club Taconic Highland | 6,532 yds |
| 13 | Mccann Memorial Golf Course | 6,524 yds |
| 14 | Beekman Country Club Valley Taconic | 6,495 yds |
| 15 | Beekman Country Club Highland Valley | 6,485 yds |
| 16 | Town of Wallkill Golf Club | 6,470 yds |
| 17 | Osiris Country Club | 6,373 yds |
| 18 | The Lynx at River Bend Golf Club | 6,257 yds |
| 19 | Powelton Club The | 6,193 yds |
| 20 | West Point Golf Course | 6,036 yds |
| 21 | Dinsmore Golf Course | 5,759 yds |
| 22 | Green Ridge Golf Club | 5,667 yds |
| 23 | Falkirk Estate Country Club | 5,644 yds |
| 24 | Storm King Golf Club | 3,149 yds |
| 25 | Dogwood Knolls Golf Course | 3,105 yds |
The longest tee set the course publishes, in yards from the tips. Compared against every course that publishes a scorecard — length is a measurement, not a verdict on the golf.
Widest tee spread
— the top 25 of 33 courses with two or more tee sets of different lengths
| # | Course | Widest tee spread |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Trump National Golf Club | 2,191 yds between tees |
| 1 | Trump National Golf Club Hudson Valley | 2,191 yds between tees |
| 3 | Golf Club at Mansion Ridge | 2,104 yds between tees |
| 4 | The Tuxedo Club | 1,850 yds between tees |
| 5 | Casperkill Golf Club | 1,817 yds between tees |
| 6 | The Links at Union Vale | 1,697 yds between tees |
| 7 | The Lynx at River Bend Golf Club | 1,646 yds between tees |
| 8 | Otterkill Golf Country Club | 1,510 yds between tees |
| 9 | Red Hook Golf Club | 1,449 yds between tees |
| 10 | Beekman Country Club Highland Valley | 1,408 yds between tees |
| 11 | West Point Golf Course | 1,386 yds between tees |
| 12 | Town of Wallkill Golf Club | 1,345 yds between tees |
| 13 | Beekman Country Club Valley Taconic | 1,327 yds between tees |
| 14 | Beekman Country Club Taconic Highland | 1,257 yds between tees |
| 15 | Mccann Memorial Golf Course | 1,209 yds between tees |
| 16 | Silo Ridge Field Club | 1,196 yds between tees |
| 17 | Dinsmore Golf Course | 1,192 yds between tees |
| 18 | Stony Ford Golf Course | 1,044 yds between tees |
| 19 | Osiris Country Club | 945 yds between tees |
| 20 | Hickory Hill Golf Course | 899 yds between tees |
| 21 | Green Ridge Golf Club | 753 yds between tees |
| 22 | Powelton Club The | 636 yds between tees |
| 23 | Harlem Valley Golf Club | 621 yds between tees |
| 24 | Millbrook Golf Tennis Club | 592 yds between tees |
| 25 | Warwick Valley Country Club | 538 yds between tees |
Yards between the longest and shortest published tee sets — how far the course moves to fit a different player. Courses publishing a single tee set are not in the running, because one set is an unmeasured spread rather than a narrow one.
Oldest
— the top 25 of 26 courses with an opening year
The year the course opened, as published. Ranked oldest first. An opening year is not a design credit and not a renovation date — a course that opened in 1921 and was rebuilt in 1998 still opened in 1921.
Highest above sea level
— the top 25 of 35 courses with a coordinate we could sample
| # | Course | Highest above sea level |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hickory Hill Golf Course | 825 ft |
| 2 | Golf Club at Mansion Ridge | 819 ft |
| 3 | Millbrook Golf Tennis Club | 665 ft |
| 4 | Town of Wallkill Golf Club | 653 ft |
| 5 | The Links at Union Vale | 637 ft |
| 6 | West Point Golf Course | 616 ft |
| 7 | Silo Ridge Field Club | 581 ft |
| 8 | Falkirk Estate Country Club | 557 ft |
| 9 | Warwick Valley Country Club | 548 ft |
| 10 | Dutcher Golf Course | 538 ft |
| 11 | Stony Ford Golf Course | 520 ft |
| 12 | The Tuxedo Club | 512 ft |
| 13 | Winding Hills Golf Club | 476 ft |
| 14 | Storm King Golf Club | 458 ft |
| 15 | Green Ridge Golf Club | 454 ft |
| 16 | The Lynx at River Bend Golf Club | 445 ft |
| 17 | Harlem Valley Golf Club | 420 ft |
| 18 | Beekman Country Club Valley Taconic | 411 ft |
| 19 | Osiris Country Club | 410 ft |
| 20 | Scenic Farms Golf Course | 384 ft |
| 21 | Otterkill Golf Country Club | 352 ft |
| 22 | Trump National Golf Club | 337 ft |
| 22 | Trump National Golf Club Hudson Valley | 337 ft |
| 24 | Red Hook Golf Club | 328 ft |
| 25 | Beekman Country Club Taconic Highland | 313 ft |
Height above sea level at the course’s own published coordinate, sampled from the USGS 3DEP elevation model. THIS IS A FIGURE WE DERIVED, not one the course publishes — anybody can re-query the same public dataset at the same coordinate and get the same number, but no scorecard states it. Because every course carries a coordinate, this is the only board here whose field is nearly the whole database rather than the courses that publish a particular figure. Elevation changes how far a ball carries; it says nothing about whether a course is good.