Skip to content
Zomma Golf
Menu

Gardiners Bay Country Club is an 18-hole private golf course in Shelter Island, New York.

It plays 6,527 yards from the Blue tees, rated 71.9/131 (checked 2026-08-21).

Create a free account to save Gardiners Bay Country Club to My Game, where every course you save is measured against the rest of its state on the figures it publishes.
18
holes
70
par
6,527
yards (tips)
131
slope (blue)
The shape of the round · Blue teespublished figures only
HOLE ORDER — BLUE TEES356548312223418567173405169391184397370472490433225394142534435465738493104113124134144155164173184PAROUT 3,171 YDSIN 3,356 YDSFIRST NINESECOND NINE
The published card in playing order, 18 holes with the two nines split — hole number under each bar, its par below that.

The course

access
private
address
12 Dinah Rock Road, Shelter Island, NY, 11965
phone
631-749-1319
elevation
48 ft derived

41.09277, -72.32874 — open on OpenStreetMap →

The course, from above

OpenStreetMap has this course's outline but has not traced any of its 18 holes. The shaded area is the property; no hole, green or tee is drawn.

The outline of Gardiners Bay Country Club as OpenStreetMap holds it, drawn over NAIP 2019 aerial imagery. No hole, green or tee has been traced inside it.

Use arrow keys to pan, plus and minus to zoom. Tab reaches the map controls.

The outline of Gardiners Bay Country Club as OpenStreetMap holds it, drawn over NAIP 2019 aerial imagery. No hole, green or tee has been traced inside it. The map itself needs JavaScript; the outline is a plain GeoJSON file either way.

Imported from OpenStreetMap, edges unchecked · USDA NAIP 2019-08-11

The outline is the whole of the traced geometry here, so there is no hole or green to jump to and nothing to measure a yardage against.

Tees & ratings

Ratingsreported, not from the clubchecked 2026-08-21

All 4 tee sets par, yardage, course rating, slope — the full table

Sorted by Yards, descending. 4 rows.

Blue70652771.913131713356
White70612470.112929363188
Gold70546066.812025902870
Red70537769.811725752802

Every figure as published; a blank cell is one nobody publishes. Front 9 and Back 9 are summed from the per-hole yardages on the scorecard.

Scorecard — every published tee

Scorecardreported, not from the clubchecked 2026-08-21

Hole 123456789101112131415161718 Total
Par 454345343434445434 70
Blue 356548312223418567173405169391184397370472490433225394 6,527
White 349511305149388544158371161386175377363429481414192371 6,124
Gold 349412305103314461158327161386175309299419411372192307 5,460
Red 341412296139314461153327132344167309299419411372174307 5,377

We don't hold a stroke index for this course's holes, so that row is not above. The yardages are every figure we hold hole by hole.

The Studio

The Studio can't plan Gardiners Bay Country Club hole by hole yet.

We hold its scorecard, but nobody has traced its holes: the bunkers, water and fairway edges a plan aims around.

It plans 4,579 courses hole by hole today, and it charts your bag anywhere.

  • The approach, planned A Studio approach map on the aerial photo: a lob wedge aimed at the island green, its spread drawn as a dashed ring over the water, and the side it most often misses. Example from another course: hole 15, Resort tee, Stadium Course at TPC Scottsdale
  • The green, from LiDAR A Studio green view on the aerial photo: arrows for the slope a LiDAR survey measured, the area a cup could be cut, and the safer side to miss. Example from another course: hole 15, Stadium Course at TPC Scottsdale
  • Every shot, tee to green A Studio plan on the aerial photo of a desert par 4: the driver off the tee and a 7-iron into the green between the bunkers, each shot with its landing spread drawn as a dashed ring. Example from another course: hole 2, Resort tee, Stadium Course at TPC Scottsdale

See the courses it plans Open the Studio

Pictures: Studio output for a sample golfer, drawn 2026-10-15. The Studio needs a free account. AI can make mistakes.

© OpenStreetMap contributors

Book nearby

Gardiners Bay Country Club states private access, so there is no tee time here to book. The nearest courses that state access you can book: Islands End Golf Country Club (2.2 mi, semi-private) · Cedars Golf Club (10 mi, public) · Poxabogue Golf Center (11 mi, public)

Measured against comparable courses

How hard and how long this course plays against comparable courses — never how good it is.

FigureThis courseIn New YorkNationwideAmong its peers
Longest6,527 yds=298th of 796=5,827th of 12,025220th of 404 in the New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ metro area · 1,928th of 2,954 private courses · =5,780th of 9,017 18-hole regulation courses
Widest tee spread1,150 yds between tees393rd of 753=7,601st of 11,523250th of 386 in the New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ metro area · =2,141st of 2,885 private courses · =7,423rd of 8,962 18-hole regulation courses
Highest above sea level48 ft derived 764th of 817=10,720th of 12,437335th of 409 in the New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ metro area · =2,551st of 3,026 private courses · =7,743rd of 9,106 18-hole regulation courses

A published figure is compared only against the courses that publish it too, which is why the totals differ from row to row — a state's length field is the courses with a scorecard, not the courses in the state. Height above sea level is the exception: we derive it from a coordinate, so its field is very nearly every course we render. Ties share an ordinal and are marked =. How this is computed →

What's on this page

In progress2 of 6 built

2 of 6 parts of this course page are built, and we're filling in the rest.

  • Scorecard, built.Par and yardage for every hole, from 4 sets of tees.
  • Course rating and slope, built.Rated from 4 sets of tees.
  • Course map, partly built.The course's outline is drawn, but none of its 18 holes has been traced in OpenStreetMap yet.
  • Per-hole distances, not built yet.The holes aren't traced yet, so there are no measured carries or distances to the green.
  • Green contours, not built yet.We haven't built the green contours for this course yet.
  • Course details, partly built.4 of 7 background details — we don't hold the architect, the year it opened and the grass on the greens.

The site is in beta and the database is still being built, so expect gaps. Know something we don't? Help us fill it in — a link to where it's published is worth more than anything else you could send.

Sources

Gathered from the course's own site and public records — every figure on this page is traceable to who published it and when. Spot an error or a gap? Tell us.

Location and identity seeded from OpenStreetMap — © OpenStreetMap contributors, ODbL. Last checked 2026-08-21. Where each figure came from is stated beside it, above.

Compare this course →

Or go straight to a comparison: vs Islands End Golf Country Club · vs Sag Harbor Golf Club · vs Noyac Golf Club

Nearby courses

Islands End Golf Country Club

2.2 mi · Greenport · semi-private · 18 holes

Sag Harbor Golf Club

7.4 mi · Sag Harbor · 9 holes

Noyac Golf Club

7.9 mi · Sag Harbor · private · 18 holes

Bridge Golf Course

7.9 mi · Bridgehampton · private · 18 holes

Atlantic Golf Club

10 mi · Bridgehampton · private · 18 holes

Cedars Golf Club

10 mi · Cutchogue · public · 9 holes

North Fork Country Club

10 mi · Cutchogue · private · 18 holes

Poxabogue Golf Center

11 mi · Bridgehampton · public · 9 holes

Straight-line distance from this course's coordinates, within 60 miles — not driving distance, and it crosses state lines where the nearest courses are over one.

Know something about this course? 11 fields we don't hold — or tell us something here is wrong